Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

From Popcorn Balls to Fun Size: How Halloween Candy Took Over Trick-or-Treating

Picture yourself coming home from trick-or-treating and dumping your Halloween haul onto the kitchen table.

There’s an apple. A homemade popcorn ball. A handful of walnuts. Some cookies.

And a nickel.

It doesn’t sound like a particularly successful Halloween by today’s standards, but there was a time when that would have been a perfectly respectable haul.

Today, Halloween and candy seem inseparable. Americans buy enormous bags of individually wrapped chocolate bars, candy corn appears on store shelves every fall, and certain houses in the neighborhood achieve legendary status by handing out full-size candy bars.

But Halloween didn’t always look like this.

Over the past century, what Americans have dropped into trick-or-treat bags has changed right along with American culture.

Before Halloween Was All About Candy

Trick-or-treating as we know it is a relatively recent American tradition.

In the early decades of the 20th century, Halloween could be a night for pranks, and sometimes fairly destructive ones. Communities began encouraging parties, parades and other organized celebrations, while the practice of children going door-to-door for treats became increasingly popular.

Those treats weren’t necessarily candy.

Children might receive homemade cookies, popcorn balls, apples, nuts or even coins. Homemade food wasn’t automatically considered suspicious. If a neighbor made cookies for the kids on the block, those cookies were part of the celebration.

After World War II, things began to change.

Trick-or-treating grew, suburbs expanded and individually packaged candy offered households a much easier way to feed an ever-growing parade of costumed children. Candy companies recognized the opportunity and increasingly marketed their products for Halloween.

When Chicken Feed Became a Halloween Icon

One of the candies most closely associated with Halloween actually predates modern trick-or-treating.

Candy corn appeared in the late 1800s as part of a larger trend of candies shaped like agricultural products. George Renninger of the Wunderle Candy Company is traditionally credited with its creation, while Goelitz Confectionery Company, now associated with Jelly Belly, began making its own version in 1898.

Its name?

Chicken Feed.

It was even sold in packaging featuring a rooster and the slogan “Something worth crowing for.”

Candy corn wasn’t originally created for Halloween and was sold year-round. But as Halloween candy marketing grew during the 20th century, those orange, yellow and white kernels already looked perfectly suited to fall.

Candy corn and Halloween found each other.

Halloween Candy Gets Weird

Candy didn’t just become more convenient. It became more fun.

Take Nik-L-Nip wax bottles. Kids could bite off the top, drink the brightly colored sugary liquid inside, chew the paraffin wax like gum—and eventually spit it out.

And then there’s PEZ.

PEZ began in Vienna in 1927 as a peppermint for adults and was marketed as an alternative to smoking. After arriving in the United States, PEZ added fruit flavors and eventually embraced character dispensers.

One of the first traditional character-head dispensers introduced in 1957?

A witch.

Halloween had helped usher PEZ into its character-head era.

When Parents Started Inspecting the Candy

By the 1970s, another cultural change was reshaping the Halloween haul.

Parents increasingly worried that strangers might tamper with treats. Stories circulated about razor blades in apples, pins in candy, and poisoned sweets.

The fear became so widespread that parents were encouraged to inspect wrappers, and some police departments and hospitals even offered to X-ray Halloween candy.

Research into reports of random Halloween candy poisoning has found remarkably little evidence that strangers were actually using trick-or-treating to seriously harm children.

But the fear changed Halloween anyway.

A homemade treat that once represented neighborhood hospitality could now look suspicious.

A sealed wrapper offered reassurance.

The Rise of Fun Size

Fortunately for candy companies, small individually wrapped candy bars were perfect for the changing holiday.

Mars introduced bars under the name Fun Size in 1968. Other candy companies liked the phrase too, which eventually led to a legal dispute over whether Mars could claim exclusive rights to it.

Tiny candy bars had a lot going for them. They were affordable enough to hand out by the handful, kids recognized the brands, parents trusted the wrappers, and nobody had to make 150 popcorn balls.

The modern trick-or-treat bag had arrived.

And Then Came the Full-Size House

Eventually, every neighborhood seemed to acquire that house.

The one that didn’t give you a tiny candy bar.

It gave you a FULL-SIZE BAR.

Word traveled. Kids told other kids. Trick-or-treating routes could be adjusted based on intelligence gathered from friends and older siblings.

And somehow, after a century of change, we’re still doing essentially the same thing people were doing when Halloween treats were homemade cookies and pocket change: neighbors opening their doors and giving kids something simply because it’s Halloween.

Listen to the Full Episode: