Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Quirky & Cool Rochester: Side Quests While Visiting the Finger Lakes

If you’re road-tripping through Western New York — maybe visiting the Finger Lakes, Niagara Falls, or even Buffalo — make a little room in your itinerary for a stop in Rochester.

It’s not flashy or overrun with tourists. Instead, it’s a city that quietly hides some of the most creative, nostalgic, and delightfully offbeat spots in the state. Over the years, as my family has spent time here visiting my father-in-law, we’ve turned Rochester into a series of side quests — each one revealing a new layer of its weird, wonderful personality.

Whether you’re into music, cocktails, or art, here are a few of my favorite quirky and cool stops that make Rochester absolutely worth the detour.

For Music Lovers

House of Guitars – “The Store That Ate My Brain”

645 Titus Ave, Irondequoit, NY
houseofguitars.com

Founded in 1964 by the Schaubroeck brothers in their mom’s basement, House of Guitars (or “HOG”) is a Rochester legend — part store, part museum, part sensory overload.

Billed as “The Largest Guitar Store in the World,” it’s a labyrinth of guitars, amps, drums, and rock memorabilia crammed into every nook and cranny of a converted Grange Hall. The walls are plastered with autographs and posters from decades of visiting artists — from Metallica and Aerosmith to The Ramones.

Their tagline says it best: “The Store That Ate My Brain.”

Pro tip: If you head to the back to check out the mountain of band t-shirts, let someone know where you’re going — it’s a maze back there! Take your time exploring; the history on those walls tells the story of rock and roll in New York State.

Record Archive – Music, Beer, and Vintage Finds

33 1/3 Rockwood St, Rochester, NY
recordarchive.com

If House of Guitars is chaos, Record Archive is curated chaos with a craft beer in hand.

Founded in 1975, this 13,000-square-foot warehouse is packed with vinyl, CDs, cassettes, and even 8-tracks. It’s also the first record store in New York State to have a full beer and wine license, so you can sip while you shop.

The Backroom Lounge hosts live shows and events, and the staff are the kind of music lovers who never judge your taste — only cheer you on. The space also sells vintage furniture, clothing, and quirky gifts, making it a destination even if you’re not a collector.

This spot is a personal favorite for my daughter, and we both love the nostalgic walk through the music we grew up with.

For the Vibe Chasers

Marge’s Lakeside Inn – A Beach Bar with History

4909 Culver Rd, Irondequoit, NY
margeslakesideinn.com

You can’t talk about Rochester without mentioning Marge’s — a beloved lakeside dive bar that’s part tiki hut, part time capsule.

The building’s story stretches back to the early 1900s. During Prohibition, it’s rumored to have been a rumrunner’s haven, with liquor coming across Lake Ontario from Canada. By 1960, Marge Beth transformed it into the cozy, quirky bar that still carries her name.

Inside, it’s all wood paneling, string lights, and fishing nets filled with trinkets — but the real magic is outside. A sandy beach patio, plastic chairs, and Lake Ontario sunsets that look like they were imported straight from the Florida Keys.

It’s the kind of spot that feels frozen in time, in the best way possible.

The Blind Pig Speakeasy – Hidden in Plain Sight

193 Main St, Fairport, NY (inside The DeLand House)
delandonmain.com/

If you prefer your cocktails with a secret entrance, The Blind Pig is your spot. Hidden in the attic of Fairport’s historic DeLand House — a 1900s French Chateau-style mansion — this modern speakeasy brings the 1920s back to life.

You’ll need a password and directions to find the hidden doorway, which adds to the fun. Once inside, it’s all candlelight, velvet, and prohibition-era charm. The small-plate menu changes weekly, and the drinks are just as creative as the concept.

Make a night of it: explore Fairport’s canal and shops before your reservation for the full small-town-meets-secret-club experience.

For Art & Nostalgia Fans

Clock of Nations – Rochester’s Whimsical Timekeeper

280 E Broad St, Rochester, NY (Tower 280 Lobby)

If you grew up in Rochester, you probably remember the Clock of Nations from Midtown Plaza — a colorful, kinetic sculpture that came to life every hour with dancing figures from around the world.

Originally installed in 1962 and gifted by Bausch + Lomb, it represented the city’s spirit of creativity and global connection. After the mall closed, the clock disappeared for years — only to be lovingly restored and brought home to Tower 280, where it still delights visitors today.

It’s one of those rare pieces of public art that bridges nostalgia and innovation — a perfect symbol of how Rochester keeps reinventing itself.

ArtisanWorks – A Living Art Wonderland

565 Blossom Rd, Suite L, Rochester, NY
artisanworks.net

If traditional galleries feel a little too quiet for you, ArtisanWorks is your antidote.

This massive, 40,000-square-foot warehouse is a kaleidoscope of paintings, sculptures, photography, and vintage oddities — more than 500,000 items in all. Founded by artist Max Pies, ArtisanWorks was created as a space where art could “live, move, and grow” alongside its community.

Every visit feels different because the artists are always reimagining the space. One corner might look like a retro diner, the next like a neon jazz club. It’s part art museum, part creative maze — and every turn invites curiosity.

Bonus: it’s also a nonprofit, with admission fees supporting local artists and creative education.

Bonus Sip Stops

If you’re planning a longer stay or just want to unwind, Rochester has a strong craft beer scene.

Here are a few personal favorites:

  • Lock 32 Brewing Co. (Pittsford) – Relaxing views of the Erie Canal.
  • Rising Storm Brewing Co. – Spacious indoor/outdoor setup with a wide beer variety.
  • Strangebird Beer – Near the Strong Museum, great pizza, full bar, and a laid-back city vibe.
  • Genesee Brewing Co. – Iconic and historic, with a tasting room overlooking High Falls. Visit in December to see the legendary Keg Tree!

Rochester is one of those cities that sneaks up on you — creative, quirky, and full of character. Whether you’re chasing music history, secret bars, or immersive art, it’s the kind of place that rewards curiosity and conversation.

If you love a good detour, this is one worth taking.

Listen to the Full Episode: